Proposed rules for independent contractors would stifle entrepreneurship
The American Dream. It’s a notion deeply woven into the fabric of our nation, each individual’s interpretation as unique as a fingerprint. For my husband and me, it’s been about carving our path as entrepreneurs after stepping away from the confines of corporate America. From that pivotal moment, we embarked on a journey of launching several businesses, each a testament to our passions, our aspirations and our willingness to embrace both success and setbacks on our own terms.
It’s this opportunity to shape our destiny that epitomizes the essence of the American economy — a landscape defined by its dynamism and resilience.
What distinguishes the American Dream is the unparalleled freedom and ingenuity it offers individuals in shaping their destinies — a liberty not easily found elsewhere in the world.
However, this hallmark of American enterprise faces a new threat. In March, officials within the U.S. Department of Labor introduced stringent regulations aimed at redefining the classification of “independent contractors” (commonly known as 1099 workers), proposing hefty fines for businesses found misclassifying workers.
In essence, these new regulations jeopardize the very foundation of flexibility and autonomy that underpin countless entrepreneurial ventures. With the proposed rules, opportunities for 1099 work will be severely curtailed, pushing individuals into traditional employment structures. This shift not only stifles the spirit of entrepreneurship, but also erects significant barriers for aspiring innovators seeking to transform ideas into viable businesses.
Reflecting on our own entrepreneurial journey, I’m reminded of the indispensable role independent contractors have played in our success. The ability to engage talent on a project basis, without the burden of full-time commitments, has been instrumental in navigating the early stages of our ventures. It’s this agility — this ability to pivot swiftly in response to evolving market demands — that defines the essence of a lean startup.
Yet, with the looming threat of overreaching regulation, entrepreneurship faces an existential crisis. The skyrocketing costs associated with compliance will dissuade many from pursuing their dreams while the gig economy, a lifeline for countless individuals, risks being rendered obsolete.
The cautionary tale of California serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of such misguided policy. Following the implementation of similar legislation, the state witnessed a precipitous decline in small businesses and the abrupt disappearance of thousands of 1099 jobs. Many disillusioned entrepreneurs sought refuge elsewhere only to now find themselves confronted with the same regulatory hurdles on a national scale.
The ramifications extend far beyond the realm of business, profoundly impacting the lives of individuals, particularly women, who have found empowerment and autonomy through independent work. As Congress deliberates on the fate of these regulations, it’s imperative that we voice our concerns and demand action.
For every consumer who relishes in the products and services offered by innovative startups, for every individual who aspires to chart their own course in the pursuit of the American Dream, now is the time to speak up. Contact your member of Congress and urge them to use the Congressional Review Act to safeguard our entrepreneurial spirit — the very essence of what makes America great.
The choice is clear: stand idly by as regulatory bodies dictate the contours of our dreams or seize the opportunity to shape a future where entrepreneurship thrives and individual autonomy reigns supreme.
Not only is this regulation not “Build Back Better” as promised by this current administration, but this is “Do Not Build at All”!
Elizabeth Nader is a board member of Jersey 1st, a non-profit organization that describes itself as being dedicated to educating and serving the hard-working people of NJ by advocating for responsible policies that will make New Jersey a better state to work, learn, live and retire. She is the host of “The Nader Narrative” on Jersey 1st TV, COO of the Common Sense Club, as well as a coach, entrepreneur and author.
Send letters to the editor and guest columns for The Jersey Journal to jjletters@jjournal.com.
